A Power struggle in Europe over who can decide what

 

 

By Tony Attwood

It is being reported that the Union of European Clubs has submitted a complaint against Uefa, accusing it of mismanagement of football in Europe.  This is a move which challenges the “memorandum of understanding” between the European Football Clubs and Uefa over who speaks for the major clubs in Europe.

The agreement, which still has around seven years to run, says that the EFC is the “sole body” representing European clubs. But the UEC, which was founded just three years ago, now has around 50 members from something like 25 national associations and challenges this view.  It too aims to be a voice for those outside the elite group of clubs and feels it should be part of the discussions about the organisation of football in Europe.

The UEC also suggests that a select group of leading clubs already holds far too much influence over how football in Europe is organised, and this situation is contrary to fundamental EU regulations concerning monopolies, and so needs to be challenged.

This challenge would itself lead to a major shake-up of football in Europe.  It would, among other things, change how clubs could gain access to places in the Champions League and Europa League (and hence gain more income).

A central part of the complaint about the Memorandum is that it is of itself, anti-competitive, and this is against a fundamental concept of the oft-quoted Article 101 of the EU Treaty, which bans anti-competitive agreements.   As a secondary argument, it is noted that it would also breach Article 102, which bans abuse of a dominant position in any area of activity within the EU.

According to current regulations, no club may join another cross-border club association unless EFC and UEFA grant permission, and that is now seen as problematic.  And indeed, it is suggested that the EFC has already told at least one club that its membership of the EFC would be ended if it chose to be part of the UEC, which is seen as an anti-competitive move and thus against EU laws.

It is also being reported that getting on for 60 members of UEC have requested that their membership be kept secret for fear of causing disruption and difficulty within the various football bodies.

In essence, this comes down to an argument about which organisation can be involved in setting the rules for football competitions – rules which can affect each participating club’s future.    As has been stated,  “Today, one association holds that mandate for all of Europe’s clubs, while most clubs have no effective voice in it. We are asking the commission to examine whether that is compatible with EU law, and to help open European football’s governance to the whole pyramid.”

And this, of course, strikes at the heart of football.  Is football free to make up its own rules – even if those rules break EU laws about competition?  In the past, the argument that “sport is different” and so not subject to all EU rules has often won the day.  But that time may have passed.

Miguel Maduro is recently quoted as saying that, “This case is about using European competition law to protect the European sports model of genuinely open and balanced competitions.”   And this takes us back to the very fundamentals of how sport rules are created.   Should sport abide by the same rules as exist in every other activity in Europe, or is it unique, and thus should not be required to abide by those rules?

Thus the argument is put…

“A system where a select group of elite clubs is given the power to decide who gets to compete in European competitions, and how the revenues are distributed, does not only harm competition in European and national football. It gradually destroys the model of open and balanced competition that Uefa itself claims to protect.”

Now, a particular part of the problem is that there is a constant pressure in football for more money to reach the clubs that are not part of the elite group – (clubs such as Real Madrid and Manchester City), which have appeared to have ceaseless access to as much money as they want.

The way in which this redistribution is proposed is via a “player development reward” within which an extra five per cent of income from club matches should go to the academies of clubs that brought through the talent, with this money being invested in the club.

However, we should not expect an immediate resolution to this matter, for it is being suggested that it could take until next spring or the EC to decide if it should be looking into the situation as requested by the UEC.

However, the UEC has said it will remove its complaint if the issues it has brought up are resolved with an agreement that all parties sign up to.

They are also probably very aware that there is still an outstanding complaint concerning competition law brought by various football leagues against Fifa, filed by the EC more than two years ago.  That is yet to reach any resolution, and that is undoubtedly holding up further action on all sides.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *